Years ago the SAT subtracted a fraction of a point for each wrong answer, and a generation of advice grew up around when to leave a question blank. That rule is gone. Today the SAT counts only correct answers, and the ACT has never penalized wrong ones. On both tests a blank and a wrong answer are worth the same: nothing.
So the first rule of guessing is simple. When time is called, no question should be empty. The rest of this article is about making those guesses worth as much as possible while spending as little time on them as possible.
What a guess is actually worth
With four answer choices, a blind guess is right one time in four. That does not sound like much, but it adds up. Guess blindly on eight questions and on average you collect two of them. Leaving those eight blank collects zero, every time.
The real gains come from elimination, because every choice you can rule out improves the odds on what remains.
| Choices you can rule out | Chance your guess is right | Expected points from 8 such guesses |
|---|---|---|
| None | 25% | 2 |
| One | 33% | About 2.7 |
| Two | 50% | 4 |
This is why "I narrowed it to two and guessed" is not a failure. It is the system working. A test taker who reliably gets hard questions down to two choices picks up half of them.
How to eliminate when you do not know the answer
You can often rule choices out without knowing how to solve the question.
- In math, estimate. If the answer must be positive, cross out the negatives. If a discounted price must be lower than the original, cross out anything higher. If the figure shows an angle that is clearly obtuse, cross out 40°.
- In reading, distrust the extreme. Choices containing "always", "never", "proves" or "completely" need very strong support in the passage, and they rarely get it. A choice that is half right is wrong.
- In grammar, find the twins. If two choices are grammatically identical, for example a period and a semicolon in the same spot, neither can be the single correct answer, so both are out.
- Everywhere, kill the off-topic choice. One choice usually talks about something the question never asked.
Pick your letter before test day
Some guesses are truly blind: thirty seconds are left and three questions remain unread. For those, decide in advance which letter you will choose, and choose it every time.
To be honest about the math, a fixed letter is not luckier than a random one. Correct answers are spread roughly evenly across the positions, so each letter is right about a quarter of the time. The advantage is speed. You spend no time deciding, you do not agonize, and you do not leave anything blank because you ran out of seconds while choosing.
The two-pass plan
Guessing well is mostly a timing skill. The mistake that costs the most points is not a bad guess. It is spending four minutes wrestling one hard question while three easy ones at the end of the module go unread.
On your first pass, answer everything you can do at a steady pace. When a question stalls you for more than a few seconds beyond its fair share, eliminate what you can, choose from what is left, flag it, and move on. The digital SAT has a "Mark for Review" button for exactly this. On the paper ACT, circle the question number in the booklet.
On your second pass, return to the flagged questions with whatever time remains. You have already banked a guess on each, so nothing is at risk. Often the answer comes more easily the second time, because another question has jogged your memory or simply because the pressure is off.
In the final minute, stop working and check that every question has an answer. That check is worth more than the one problem you were in the middle of.
Guessing on type-in math questions
About a quarter of SAT math questions have no answer choices. You type a number instead. Blind guessing rarely works there, but an educated entry is still better than an empty box. If the question asks for a slope and the line clearly rises gently, enter a small positive fraction. If you got partway and have a candidate, enter it. There is still no penalty.
One thing guessing cannot fix
All of this recovers points at the margins, typically a handful per test. It is worth doing, and it is not a substitute for knowing the material. If you find yourself guessing on the same kind of question every time, that pattern is the most useful thing a practice test can tell you, because it names exactly what to study next.